Payton Tolle MLB The Show 26

99 OVR|Red DiamondRed Diamond rarity|Starting Pitcher|Meta Score: 100.00
Payton Tolle

All Versions

Payton Tolle Card Details - MLB The Show 26

This is the 2026 Finest card for Payton Tolle, featured in MLB The Show 26. He's a 99 Overall Red Diamond card primarily playing SP. Payton Tolle has an elite Meta Score of 100.00, indicating the card's overall effectiveness in competitive play. On the mound, Payton Tolle exhibits elite H/9 with a 116 rating, elite K/9 with a 110 rating, and elite BB/9 with a 114 rating. With runners threatening, his Pitching Clutch rating of 110 shows elite performance. His overall pitching profile is defined by elite control with a Control rating of 99, elite velocity with a Velocity rating of 99, and elite break with a Break rating of 99. As a starting pitcher, his stamina is elite with a rating of 105. He utilizes a 5-pitch mix, spearheaded by a 4-Seam Fastball, complemented by a Sinker. Key pitches include: 4-Seam Fastball, Sinker, Cutter, Slurve, Circle Change. Payton Tolle's card information lists age 23, height 6'6", weight 250 lbs, birthplace Oklahoma, team Red Sox, bats L, and throws L. Active Quirks for Payton Tolle: Homebody, Night Player, Break Outlier. Other available versions for Payton Tolle include: Topps Now (97 Diamond), Mural (94 Diamond), Live (79 Silver), Live (63 Common).

Pitch Combinations

Tunneling
SinkerSinker
+
CutterCutter
★★★★★
4-Seam Fastball4-Seam Fastball
+
Circle ChangeCircle Change
★★★★☆
SinkerSinker
+
Circle ChangeCircle Change
★★★★☆
4-Seam Fastball4-Seam Fastball
+
SlurveSlurve
★★★☆☆

Quirks

Homebody
Homebody
Night Player
Night Player
Break Outlier
Break Outlier

Other Versions

There are no other MLB The Show 26 versions of this player currently available.

Basic Information

Age23Physical6'6" • 250 lbsBirthplaceOklahoma
TeamRed SoxTheme TeamBest Red Sox Diamond Dynasty LineupJersey Number#70
PrimaryStarting PitcherRankingsTop 25 Starting Pitcher
BatsLThrowsLSeries2026 FinestRarityRed DiamondSetCOREMeta Score100.00