MLB The Show 25 Captains

Complete database of all 60 captain cards featuring 10,128 compatible player combinations across all tiers

Alfonso Soriano

CHC

Players from the Chicago Cubs 91 OVR or lower

Alfonso Soriano
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
Clutch: +15
H/9: +15
67 Players Compatible
Diamond6
Gold10
Silver16
Bronze20
Common13

Andrew Benintendi

CWS

Players from the Chicago White Sox 95 OVR or lower

Andrew Benintendi
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Vision: +5
BB/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Vision: +10
BB/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
Vision: +15
BB/9: +15
53 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold7
Silver13
Bronze15
Common10

Andrew McCutchen

PIT

Players from the Pittsburgh Pirates 91 OVR or lower

Andrew McCutchen
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
Clutch: +15
H/9: +15
58 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze17
Common11

Andrew Miller

CLE

Players from the Cleveland Guardians 91 OVR or lower

Andrew Miller
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +8
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
Clutch: +15
H/9: +12
56 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze16
Common11

Austin Riley

ATL

Players from the Atlanta Braves 95 OVR or lower

Austin Riley
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +3
Power Left: +3
Vision: +3
K/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +5
Power Left: +5
Vision: +5
K/9: +8
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +8
Power Left: +8
Vision: +8
K/9: +10
53 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold7
Silver13
Bronze15
Common10

Babe Ruth

NYY

Players from the New York Yankees 91 OVR or lower

Babe Ruth
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +8
Contact Left: +8
Clutch: +8
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +15
71 Players Compatible
Diamond7
Gold10
Silver17
Bronze21
Common14

Ben Joyce

LAA

Players from the Los Angeles Angels 95 OVR or lower

Ben Joyce
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +3
Power Left: +3
K/9: +5
Speed: +3
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +5
Power Left: +5
K/9: +10
Speed: +5
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +8
Power Left: +8
K/9: +15
Speed: +8
59 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze17
Common11

Blake Treinen

LAD

Players from the Los Angeles Dodgers 95 OVR or lower

Blake Treinen
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +2
Power Left: +2
Pitch Clutch: +2
Arm Strength: +2
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +4
Power Left: +4
Pitch Clutch: +4
Arm Strength: +4
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +6
Power Left: +6
Pitch Clutch: +6
Arm Strength: +6
70 Players Compatible
Diamond7
Gold10
Silver17
Bronze21
Common14

Bo Naylor

CLE

Players from the Cleveland Guardians 95 OVR or lower

Bo Naylor
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +5
Power Left: +5
Fielding: +5
K/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +8
Power Left: +8
Fielding: +8
K/9: +8
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +10
Power Left: +10
Fielding: +10
K/9: +10
56 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze16
Common11

Bobby Grich

LAA

Players from the Los Angeles Angels 91 OVR or lower

Bobby Grich
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
H/9: +5
Pitch Clutch: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
H/9: +13
Pitch Clutch: +13
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
H/9: +20
Pitch Clutch: +20
59 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze17
Common11

Brent Rooker

OAK

Players from the Athletics 95 OVR or lower

Brent Rooker
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +5
Power Left: +5
Batting Clutch: +5
H/9: +8
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +8
Power Left: +8
Batting Clutch: +8
H/9: +12
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +12
Power Left: +12
Batting Clutch: +12
H/9: +15
61 Players Compatible
Diamond6
Gold9
Silver15
Bronze18
Common12

Bryan Abreu

HOU

Players from the Houston Astros 95 OVR or lower

Bryan Abreu
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +5
Power Left: +5
Speed: +5
K/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +8
Power Left: +8
Speed: +8
K/9: +8
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +10
Power Left: +10
Speed: +10
K/9: +10
59 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze17
Common11

Bryan Woo

SEA

Players from the Seattle Mariners 95 OVR or lower

Bryan Woo
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +5
Power Left: +5
Vision: +5
BB/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +8
Power Left: +8
Vision: +8
BB/9: +8
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +10
Power Left: +10
Vision: +10
BB/9: +10
54 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver13
Bronze16
Common10

Cal Ripken Jr.

BAL

Players from the Baltimore Orioles 91 OVR or lower

Cal Ripken Jr.
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +8
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +13
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
Clutch: +15
H/9: +20
59 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze17
Common11

Clay Buchholz

BOS

Players from the Boston Red Sox 91 OVR or lower

Clay Buchholz
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +1
Contact Left: +1
Clutch: +1
H/9: +3
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +3
Contact Left: +3
Clutch: +3
H/9: +5
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +8
63 Players Compatible
Diamond6
Gold9
Silver15
Bronze18
Common12

Colton Cowser

BAL

Players from the Baltimore Orioles 95 OVR or lower

Colton Cowser
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Power Right: +5
Batting Clutch: +5
H/9: +8
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Power Right: +10
Batting Clutch: +10
H/9: +13
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Power Right: +15
Batting Clutch: +15
H/9: +20
59 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze17
Common11

Craig Biggio

HOU

Players from the Houston Astros 91 OVR or lower

Craig Biggio
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Pitch Clutch: +10
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
Pitch Clutch: +15
H/9: +15
59 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze17
Common11

Ezequiel Tovar

COL

Players from the Colorado Rockies 95 OVR or lower

Ezequiel Tovar
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Left: +5
Vision: +5
Fielding: +5
BB/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Power Left: +10
Vision: +10
Fielding: +8
BB/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Power Left: +15
Vision: +15
Fielding: +10
BB/9: +15
51 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold7
Silver12
Bronze15
Common10

Frank Thomas

CWS

Players from the Chicago White Sox 91 OVR or lower

Frank Thomas
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
Clutch: +15
H/9: +15
53 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold7
Silver13
Bronze15
Common10

George Brett

KC

Players from the Kansas City Royals 91 OVR or lower

George Brett
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
Clutch: +15
H/9: +15
51 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold7
Silver12
Bronze15
Common10

Hank Thompson

SF

Players from the San Francisco Giants 91 OVR or lower

Hank Thompson
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
Clutch: +15
H/9: +15
56 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze16
Common11

Ian Kinsler

TEX

Players from the Texas Rangers 91 OVR or lower

Ian Kinsler
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Pitch Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Pitch Clutch: +10
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
Pitch Clutch: +15
H/9: +15
63 Players Compatible
Diamond6
Gold9
Silver15
Bronze18
Common12

J.T. Realmuto

PHI

Players from the Philadelphia Phillies 95 OVR or lower

J.T. Realmuto
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Left: +5
Power Left: +5
Speed: +3
Pitch Clutch: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Left: +8
Power Left: +8
Speed: +5
Pitch Clutch: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Left: +10
Power Left: +10
Speed: +8
Pitch Clutch: +15
63 Players Compatible
Diamond6
Gold9
Silver15
Bronze18
Common12

Jack Leiter

TEX

Players from the Texas Rangers 95 OVR or lower

Jack Leiter
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +3
Power Left: +3
Pitch Clutch: +3
Speed: +3
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +5
Power Left: +5
Pitch Clutch: +5
Speed: +5
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +8
Power Left: +8
Pitch Clutch: +8
Speed: +8
63 Players Compatible
Diamond6
Gold9
Silver15
Bronze18
Common12

Jackson Jobe

DET

Players from the Detroit Tigers 91 OVR or lower

Jackson Jobe
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
Clutch: +15
H/9: +15
57 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze17
Common11

Jake Cronenworth

SD

Players from the San Diego Padres 95 OVR or lower

Jake Cronenworth
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +5
Vision: +5
Reaction: +5
Pitch Clutch: +5
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +8
Vision: +8
Reaction: +8
Pitch Clutch: +8
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +10
Vision: +10
Reaction: +10
Pitch Clutch: +10
56 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze16
Common11

James Wood

WSH

Players from the Washington Nationals 91 OVR or lower

James Wood
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
H/9: +5
Clutch: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
H/9: +10
Clutch: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
H/9: +15
Clutch: +15
0 Players Compatible

Jared Jones

PIT

Players from the Pittsburgh Pirates 95 OVR or lower

Jared Jones
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +5
Power Left: +5
Pitch Clutch: +5
Arm Strength: +3
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +8
Power Left: +8
Pitch Clutch: +8
Arm Strength: +5
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +10
Power Left: +10
Pitch Clutch: +10
Arm Strength: +8
58 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze17
Common11

Javier Báez

DET

Players from the Detroit Tigers 95 OVR or lower

Javier Báez
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +5
Power Left: +5
K/9: +5
Reaction: +5
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +8
Power Left: +8
K/9: +8
Reaction: +8
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +10
Power Left: +10
K/9: +10
Reaction: +10
57 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze17
Common11

Jeff Hoffman

TOR

Players from the Toronto Blue Jays 95 OVR or lower

Jeff Hoffman
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +3
Power Left: +3
Batting Clutch: +3
H/9: +3
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +7
Power Left: +7
Batting Clutch: +7
H/9: +7
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +10
Power Left: +10
Batting Clutch: +10
H/9: +10
55 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver13
Bronze16
Common11

Jim Edmonds

STL

Players from the St. Louis Cardinals 91 OVR or lower

Jim Edmonds
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
Clutch: +15
H/9: +15
62 Players Compatible
Diamond6
Gold9
Silver15
Bronze18
Common12

Jim Kaat

MIN

Players from the Minnesota Twins 91 OVR or lower

Jim Kaat
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +8
Contact Left: +8
Clutch: +8
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +12
Contact Left: +12
Clutch: +12
H/9: +15
56 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze16
Common11

Joe Musgrove

SD

Players from the San Diego Padres 91 OVR or lower

Joe Musgrove
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
Clutch: +15
H/9: +15
56 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze16
Common11

John Franco

NYM

Players from the New York Mets 91 OVR or lower

John Franco
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +8
Contact Left: +8
Clutch: +8
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +15
59 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze17
Common11

Johnny Bench

CIN

Players from the Cincinnati Reds 91 OVR or lower

Johnny Bench
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
Clutch: +15
H/9: +15
59 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze17
Common11

Josh Lowe

TB

Players from the Tampa Bay Rays 95 OVR or lower

Josh Lowe
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +8
Power Right: +8
H/9: +8
Speed: +3
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +13
Power Right: +13
H/9: +13
Speed: +5
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +20
Power Right: +20
H/9: +20
Speed: +8
54 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver13
Bronze16
Common10

Jung Hoo Lee

SF

Players from the San Francisco Giants 95 OVR or lower

Jung Hoo Lee
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Power Left: +5
Vision: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Power Left: +10
Vision: +10
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Power Left: +15
Vision: +15
H/9: +15
56 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze16
Common11

Junior Caminero

TB

Players from the Tampa Bay Rays 91 OVR or lower

Junior Caminero
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +8
Contact Left: +8
Clutch: +8
H/9: +8
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +13
Contact Left: +13
Clutch: +13
H/9: +13
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +20
Contact Left: +20
Clutch: +20
H/9: +20
54 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver13
Bronze16
Common10

Justin Martinez

ARI

Players from the Arizona Diamondbacks 91 OVR or lower

Justin Martinez
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
Clutch: +15
H/9: +15
51 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold7
Silver12
Bronze15
Common10

Keibert Ruiz

WSH

Players from the Washington Nationals 95 OVR or lower

Keibert Ruiz
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +5
Power Left: +5
Vision: +5
K/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +8
Power Left: +8
Vision: +8
K/9: +8
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +10
Power Left: +10
Vision: +10
K/9: +10
0 Players Compatible

Kyle Schwarber

PHI

Players from the Philadelphia Phillies 91 OVR or lower

Kyle Schwarber
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +8
Contact Left: +8
Clutch: +8
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +15
63 Players Compatible
Diamond6
Gold9
Silver15
Bronze18
Common12

Lourdes Gurriel Jr.

ARI

Players from the Arizona Diamondbacks 95 OVR or lower

Lourdes Gurriel Jr.
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +5
Power Left: +5
Vision: +5
K/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +8
Power Left: +8
Vision: +8
K/9: +8
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +10
Power Left: +10
Vision: +10
K/9: +10
51 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold7
Silver12
Bronze15
Common10

Luis Gil

NYY

Players from the New York Yankees 95 OVR or lower

Luis Gil
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +1
Power Left: +1
K/9: +1
Arm Strength: +1
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +3
Power Left: +3
K/9: +3
Arm Strength: +3
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +5
Power Left: +5
K/9: +5
Arm Strength: +5
71 Players Compatible
Diamond7
Gold10
Silver17
Bronze21
Common14

Mark Vientos

NYM

Players from the New York Mets 95 OVR or lower

Mark Vientos
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +3
Power Left: +3
Arm Strength: +3
K/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +5
Power Left: +5
Arm Strength: +5
K/9: +8
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +8
Power Left: +8
Arm Strength: +8
K/9: +10
59 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze17
Common11

Masataka Yoshida

BOS

Players from the Boston Red Sox 95 OVR or lower

Masataka Yoshida
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +2
Power Left: +2
Vision: +2
BB/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +4
Power Left: +4
Vision: +4
BB/9: +8
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +6
Power Left: +6
Vision: +6
BB/9: +10
63 Players Compatible
Diamond6
Gold9
Silver15
Bronze18
Common12

Matt Holliday

OAK

Players from the Athletics

Matt Holliday
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +8
Contact Left: +8
Clutch: +8
H/9: +8
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +13
Contact Left: +13
Clutch: +13
H/9: +13
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +20
Contact Left: +20
Clutch: +20
H/9: +20
61 Players Compatible
Diamond6
Gold9
Silver15
Bronze18
Common12

Max Muncy

LAD

Players from the Los Angeles Dodgers 91 OVR or lower

Max Muncy
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +3
Contact Left: +3
Clutch: +3
H/9: +3
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +8
Contact Left: +8
Clutch: +8
H/9: +8
70 Players Compatible
Diamond7
Gold10
Silver17
Bronze21
Common14

Michael Wacha

KC

Players from the Kansas City Royals 95 OVR or lower

Michael Wacha
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +5
Power Left: +5
Fielding: +5
BB/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +8
Power Left: +8
Fielding: +8
BB/9: +8
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +10
Power Left: +10
Fielding: +10
BB/9: +10
51 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold7
Silver12
Bronze15
Common10

Nick Lodolo

CIN

Players from the Cincinnati Reds 95 OVR or lower

Nick Lodolo
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +5
Power Left: +5
Vision: +5
K/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +8
Power Left: +8
Vision: +8
K/9: +8
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +10
Power Left: +10
Vision: +10
K/9: +10
59 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze17
Common11

Nico Hoerner

CHC

Players from the Chicago Cubs 95 OVR or lower

Nico Hoerner
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +5
Fielding: +5
Vision: +5
BB/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +10
Vision: +10
Fielding: +8
BB/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +15
Vision: +15
Fielding: +10
BB/9: +15
67 Players Compatible
Diamond6
Gold10
Silver16
Bronze20
Common13

Preston Wilson

MIA

Players from the Miami Marlins 91 OVR or lower

Preston Wilson
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +8
Contact Left: +8
Clutch: +8
H/9: +8
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +13
Contact Left: +13
Clutch: +13
H/9: +13
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +20
Contact Left: +20
Clutch: +20
H/9: +20
55 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver13
Bronze16
Common11

Richie Sexson

SEA

Players from the Seattle Mariners 91 OVR or lower

Richie Sexson
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
H/9: +5
Pitch Clutch: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
H/9: +10
Pitch Clutch: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
H/9: +15
Pitch Clutch: +15
54 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver13
Bronze16
Common10

Rollie Fingers

MIL

Players from the Milwaukee Brewers 91 OVR or lower

Rollie Fingers
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
Clutch: +15
H/9: +15
57 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze17
Common11

Roy Halladay

TOR

Players from the Toronto Blue Jays 91 OVR or lower

Roy Halladay
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
Clutch: +15
H/9: +15
55 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver13
Bronze16
Common11

Royce Lewis

MIN

Players from the Minnesota Twins 95 OVR or lower

Royce Lewis
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +3
Power Left: +3
BB/9: +5
Vision: +3
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +5
Power Left: +5
BB/9: +8
Vision: +5
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +8
Power Left: +8
BB/9: +12
Vision: +8
56 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze16
Common11

Sal Frelick

MIL

Players from the Milwaukee Brewers 95 OVR or lower

Sal Frelick
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +5
Vision: +5
Fielding: +3
BB/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +8
Vision: +8
Fielding: +5
BB/9: +8
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +10
Vision: +10
Fielding: +8
BB/9: +10
57 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver14
Bronze17
Common11

Todd Helton

COL

Players from the Colorado Rockies 91 OVR or lower

Todd Helton
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +15
Contact Left: +15
Clutch: +15
H/9: +15
51 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold7
Silver12
Bronze15
Common10

Tom Glavine

ATL

Players from the Atlanta Braves 91 OVR or lower

Tom Glavine
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +5
Contact Left: +5
Clutch: +5
H/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +8
Contact Left: +8
Clutch: +8
H/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +10
Contact Left: +10
Clutch: +10
H/9: +15
53 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold7
Silver13
Bronze15
Common10

Victor Scott II

STL

Players from the St. Louis Cardinals 95 OVR or lower

Victor Scott II
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Power Right: +5
Speed: +3
Fielding: +3
BB/9: +5
Tier 2
12
Power Right: +10
Speed: +5
Fielding: +5
BB/9: +10
Tier 3
18
Power Right: +15
Speed: +8
Fielding: +8
BB/9: +15
62 Players Compatible
Diamond6
Gold9
Silver15
Bronze18
Common12

Xavier Edwards

MIA

Players from the Miami Marlins 95 OVR or lower

Xavier Edwards
Tier
REQ
Boost
Tier 1
5
Contact Right: +8
Contact Left: +8
Speed: +5
H/9: +8
Tier 2
12
Contact Right: +13
Contact Left: +13
Speed: +8
H/9: +13
Tier 3
18
Contact Right: +20
Contact Left: +20
Speed: +10
H/9: +20
55 Players Compatible
Diamond5
Gold8
Silver13
Bronze16
Common11

Frequently Asked Questions

How many captain cards are in MLB The Show 25?

MLB The Show 25 features 60 unique captain cards, each with their own boost abilities and compatible player requirements across multiple tiers.

How do captain tiers work in Diamond Dynasty?

Captain cards have three tiers of boosts that unlock as you add more compatible players to your lineup. Each tier provides increasingly powerful boosts to help enhance your team's performance. Check our player database to find compatible players.

Which captain has the most compatible players?

Compatible player counts vary by captain requirements. Team-based captains typically have fewer but more focused compatible players, while broader requirement captains may have larger pools. Use our lineup builder to optimize your captain strategy.

Can I use multiple captains in one lineup?

No, you can only use one captain at a time in Diamond Dynasty. Choose your captain based on your team composition and the boosts that best complement your top players and strategy.

MLB The Show 25 Captain System Guide

Master the MLB The Show 25 captain system with our comprehensive database featuring 60 unique captain cards and 10,128 compatible player combinations. Captain cards represent one of the most powerful team-building mechanics in Diamond Dynasty, offering progressive attribute boosts that can transform your lineup's performance. Each captain requires specific player types to unlock their full potential through a three-tier progression system, rewarding strategic roster construction with increasingly valuable bonuses. Use our Diamond Dynasty team builder to experiment with different captain strategies and discover optimal player combinations that maximize your team's attribute ceiling.

Understanding captain mechanics is essential for competitive Diamond Dynasty success in MLB The Show 25. Our captain database provides detailed information about each card's requirements, boost effects, and compatible player pools, helping you make informed decisions about which captain best suits your collection and playstyle. From team-specific captains that require players from particular organizations to position-based captains focusing on specific defensive roles, each captain type offers unique advantages for different lineup strategies. Explore our complete player database to identify compatible players for your chosen captain, and check ourteam rosters for natural synergies between captains and available player pools.

The captain system in MLB The Show 25 rewards long-term collection building and strategic planning, making captain selection a crucial decision for serious Diamond Dynasty players. Our comprehensive captain guide breaks down each card's tier requirements, boost effects, and optimal usage scenarios, ensuring you choose the captain that best complements your existing roster and collection goals. Whether you're building around specific card series, focusing on particular teams, or targeting position-specific boosts, the right captain choice can significantly impact your team's performance ceiling. Use our player comparison toolto evaluate how captain boosts affect your key players, and stay updated with our position rankings to identify the most effective captain-compatible players for competitive online play in MLB The Show 25.

Cookie Consent

This website uses cookies to enhance your browsing experience and analyze site traffic.

By clicking 'Accept', you consent to our use of cookies as described in our privacy policy.